Pin
If you want juicy, tasty steaks without breaking the bank or using fancy stuff, this simple marinade has you covered. I reach for it every time I’m craving steakhouse vibes with almost zero hassle. My family’s always surprised it turns out so good, even with cheap cuts.
A little story—there was one year we grilled steak basically every Saturday and this marinade was always our trick. Rain or shine, whatever steak we picked, it always pulled off steakhouse-level flavor at our place.
Delicious Ingredients
- Optional garlic herb butter for finishing: for that classic steakhouse touch Just use some real butter and toss in your fave fresh herbs
- Steak: grab your favorite—sirloin, ribeye, strip, or filet Try for good marbling and a lovely red color
- Garlic powder: brings extra flavor without worrying about it burning Try to get a salt-free version
- Ground black pepper: adds just the right kick Go fresh-cracked if you want more punch
- Dijon mustard: has a little tang that mixes in smooth Look for a creamy one so it blends easy
- Brown sugar: helps everything caramelize and balances that tanginess If you have dark brown, it’s even better
- Pineapple juice: makes your steak extra tender and gives a sweet note Fresh or unsweetened is great
- Worcestershire sauce: adds bold, savory flavor If you can, find a brand that uses real anchovies
- Low sodium soy sauce: lowers the salt while still bringing that umami magic Stick to naturally brewed if possible
- Balsamic vinegar: packs a tasty tang with a bit of sweet If you can, splurge for the aged stuff
- Extra virgin olive oil: deepens flavor and helps the marinade soak in A good bottle makes it all smell fresh
Simple Instructions
- Make Garlic Herb Butter Optional:
- Soften butter, then mix in chopped rosemary, parsley, thyme and garlic. Roll into a log with plastic or parchment, chill in the fridge, then slice and put it on your hot steak for bonus flavor.
- Rest and Serve:
- Take steaks off the grill and lay foil over them. Let ‘em chill for five minutes, so the juices spread out and every bite is super juicy.
- Dry and Grill the Steak:
- Pull steaks out and pat them dry really well with paper towels. This helps the crust turn brown and tasty. Grill to your favorite doneness—use a thermometer if you want to be sure.
- Prepare the Grill:
- Fire up your grill to medium-high, then brush on some oil so those steaks don’t stick and get a perfect sear.
- Marinate the Steaks:
- Drop the steaks in a glass dish or big zip bag and pour over the marinade. Make sure everything’s covered, then seal it shut or wrap the dish, chill in the fridge at least four hours (overnight’s even better). Short on time? Even an hour helps.
- Combine Marinade Ingredients:
- Add garlic powder, black pepper, Dijon, brown sugar, pineapple juice, Worcestershire, soy sauce, balsamic, and olive oil to a big bowl or measuring cup. Whisk until it’s all one smooth mix that coats every steak evenly.
Pin
The splash of pineapple juice is my secret move for making steak extra tender, plus a kiss of sweetness. Nothing gets my kids more excited than smelling that buttery, garlicky goodness wafting from the grill.
Leftover Tips
Tuck any leftover steak in an airtight box in the fridge—they’ll keep for up to three days after cooking. Going to freeze? Slice it up first so you can reheat just what you need. That way, it won’t get dry.
Easy Swaps
Out of pineapple juice? Apple or orange juice tastes sweet and does the trick. For gluten-free, use coconut aminos instead of soy sauce. No Dijon? Stone ground mustard fills in nicely.
Tasty Ways to Eat
Serve your steaks with crunchy green salads, roasted veggies, or a good baked potato. For something a little fancier, try some garlic herb butter and toss in crusty bread. Got leftovers? My family loves making steak sandwiches and tossing chopped steak into salads the next day.
Pin
Fun Backstory
Marinating meat’s been around forever—tons of cultures do it. In the US, we love mixes that are a little sweet, a little tangy, a little salty—kind of like the food customs that came together here. Growing up in the Midwest, everybody had some marinade passed down from a grill-happy uncle or aunt.
Recipe FAQs
- → How long does steak need to soak for max flavor?
If you've got the time, give it 4 to 24 hours—steaks just get better the longer they marinate. Only got an hour? That’ll do in a hurry.
- → Which steak cuts taste great with this?
It’s awesome on strip, ribeye, filet, sirloin, or just about any steak you like. Use what you’ve got or your favorite.
- → Should I dry steaks before tossing them on the grill?
For sure! Pat them down so there’s not too much marinade on the outside. That way you won't get flare-ups and you'll get that golden crust.
- → Why bother with garlic herb butter at the end?
That buttery topping melts over your steak, bringing loads of fresh herby taste and just makes every bite extra special.
- → Can I throw this marinade on something besides steak?
Go for it! It’s tasty on chicken, pork, and even veggies—gives ‘em that deep, savory kick.
- → Do I really need an instant-read thermometer?
It’s super handy for nailing the doneness you want, so your steak stays nice and juicy every time.