Pin
Packed with spicy kick and drenched in creamy sauce, this Cajun shrimp dish is my top pick when I want something fast but guaranteed to win folks over. Succulent shrimp bubble away in a cheesy, peppery sauce that’s knockout over pasta or rice. There’s never a spoonful left whenever I serve it.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Lime wedges and fresh cilantro: Toss these on top for a zesty, fresh finish. Pick bright green herbs for the best vibe.
- Cayenne pepper and red pepper flakes: Toss some in for as much heat as you like. Dial back or skip if you want it mild.
- Mustard powder and oregano: Just a pinch of these will punch up the flavor. Sniff your oregano to make sure it’s still fragrant.
- Brown sugar: A smidge tones down the heat. Light brown sugar is totally fine.
- Lime juice: Squirt in some for brightness! Go for fresh limes if possible.
- Cheddar jack cheese: Shredded cheese makes everything gooey. Use a block and grate it yourself for the best melt.
- Rotel diced tomatoes with green chilies: Use these for tang and a gentle burn. If you want less spice, regular diced tomatoes work, too.
- Hot sauce: Pour in your fave—Frank’s is a good move. Add a little or a lot depending on your fire level.
- Honey: Sweetens and balances out the spicy. Raw honey adds extra depth.
- Heavy cream or half and half: Cream brings everything together. Any type is good—higher fat means richer sauce.
- Chicken broth: Goes in for deep, savory flavor. Pick low-sodium so you can season how you like.
- Flour: Sprinkle in to make the sauce thick and silky. All-purpose is your best bet.
- Garlic: Fresh, chopped-up garlic packs a punch. Don’t use pre-minced if you can help it.
- Butter: Keeps things creamy and smooth. Unsalted lets you be the boss of the salt.
- Olive or avocado oil: Either will do the job for searing. Avocado oil is awesome for higher heat.
- Red bell pepper: These give crunch and a touch of sweet. Grab the firmest, shiniest ones.
- Cajun seasoning: The soul of this dish. Go for a good blend, or toss together your own if you watch salt.
- Uncooked shrimp: Big shrimp = juicy bites. Peel and clean for speedier prep.
Easy Instructions
- Bring Everyone Together and Finish Off:
- Toss those cooked shrimp and peppers back in with the dreamy sauce. Throw in lime wedges and sprinkle chopped cilantro on top. Serve it all up over pasta, rice, or even a handful of salad greens.
- Add Cheese and Lime Juice:
- With the pan off the burner, start stirring in cheese a bit at a time. Make sure it melts before adding the next handful. Finish by squirting in fresh lime juice for tang.
- Let the Sauce Come Together:
- Gently pour your broth and cream mix in, whisking so it stays smooth. Now’s when you add those drained tomatoes. Let it simmer about ten minutes so it thickens up and looks shiny.
- Make the Roux:
- Drop in the butter, then add garlic right away. Give it a quick stir—just until it smells awesome. Sprinkle over the flour and whisk two minutes so it loses that raw taste. You want a flawless sauce at the end.
- Deglaze and Build Up Flavors:
- Pour in the juice you saved from the tomatoes and scrape up all the browned bits left in the pan. Let it bubble down to half—this amps up every bit of flavor you don’t want to waste.
- Cook the Shrimp:
- Toss the shrimp in Cajun spice so every nook is covered. Get your skillet hot with oil and drop in shrimp and peppers. Sear each side just over a minute—move them to a plate right after to keep them juicy.
- Prep Shrimp and Gather Your Sauce Stuff:
- Pat your shrimp as dry as possible after you peel and clean them. This way, they’ll brown up nicely. Drain the tomatoes, saving their juice for extra zest. Whisk together broth, cream, honey, hot sauce, and seasonings in a bowl—the rest will go fast after that.
Pin
The melty bits of Cheddar Jack cheese are what I look forward to most, and my daughter tries to steal the sauciest bites every time. We always have a little ‘is it spicy enough?’ taste test at the counter.
Leftover Wisdom
Pop leftovers into a sealed container in the fridge—they’ll be good for up to three days. The sauce stays silky but reheat gently on the stove so it doesn’t separate. If you’re freezing, chill the shrimp first, then use a freezer-friendly container. When ready to eat, thaw overnight in the fridge. Warm it all up slowly in a skillet—just don’t boil or the shrimp might toughen up.
Swap Options
Skip the dairy by using full-fat coconut milk and a dairy-free cheese (or none at all). Extra bell pepper or some corn will make it heartier. No Rotel? Use plain diced tomatoes plus a chopped mild green chili to mimic the flavor.
Pin
How to Serve
My favorite way is over fluffy rice or slippery noodles, but it’s also next-level inside warm tortillas with a bit of extra cilantro and lime. Add a little sour cream if you like. A side salad or some simple black beans is perfect to cut the richness.
Backstory and Tradition
Cajun food is the soul of Louisiana cooking—it’s all about punchy layers from garlic, cayenne, peppers, and more. This dish mixes those big bold spices with a creamy skillet sauce, giving you that bayou comfort in a weeknight-friendly package.
Recipe FAQs
- → Which size shrimp do you recommend?
Go for the big ones—roughly 26-30 in a pound. They stay nice and juicy as you quickly toss them in the pan and dunk them in that creamy sauce.
- → How do I make it less (or more) spicy?
Easy—cut back on the hot sauce and skip the cayenne if you want it mild. Or pour on more if you’re all about the heat. Fix it to match your taste buds.
- → Can I swap Rotel for something else?
Yep! Canned diced tomatoes do the trick. Toss in a bit of diced green chile if you want a little extra kick.
- → What cheese is best for meltiness?
Mozzarella, Monterey Jack, Cheddar, and Cheddar Jack all melt nicely. Grab a block and shred it yourself for the smoothest sauce.
- → How do I warm up leftovers without ruining the shrimp?
Pop it back on the stove with medium heat. Just heat it slowly and don’t let it go too long, so those shrimp don’t get rubbery.
- → Can I stash this away in the freezer?
Totally. Let it cool all the way, then seal it tight and freeze for up to about three months. Defrost before you heat it up again.