Pin
Nothing says comfort food like a good old apple pie. The smell of cinnamon and apples drifting out of the oven brings back the coziest memories from when I was little. Flaky pastry with soft, spiced apples makes this treat something folks never outgrow.
After our first round of apple picking one fall, I tried this out for my crew. Now they beg for it when the leaves turn. Even the picky ones go in for another slice.
Delicious Ingredients
- Lemon juice: keeps everything bright and makes those apples stay their pretty color, fresh-squeezed works best
- Ground nutmeg: just a pinch takes the filling up a notch, fresh grated is really nice if you have it
- Ground cinnamon: gets the kitchen smelling amazing, use fresh and you’ll notice the difference
- Apples: the main event—go for tart, sturdy kinds like Granny Smith or Honeycrisp to keep everything from getting mushy
- Ice water: super cold so the crust stays flaky, straight from the fridge is perfect
- Unsalted butter: makes dough taste rich and bake up with lots of layers, use real butter and keep it chilled
- Sugar: gentle sweetness and helps the pie get toasty on top, plain granulated works for both crust and apples
- Salt: bumps up all the good flavors, fine salt mixes in quickest
- All-purpose flour: gives you a crust that’s sturdy but soft, stick with flour that hasn’t been sitting around
Simple How-To
- Bake and Cool:
- Put your pie low down in the oven. Start with the heat cranked, baking 15 minutes so the layers set. Turn the temp down, then keep baking 35–45 minutes. It’s ready when fruit is soft and juices bubble right out of the top holes. Let it sit until totally cool so each piece stays together.
- Fill and Put Together:
- Spoon your apple mix into the bottom crust. Lay the other rolled-out dough over the fruit, trim, seal the edges with a squeeze, and then cut a few tiny vents so steam can escape.
- Prep the Filling:
- Toss apple slices in a bowl with flour, cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar, and lemon juice. Make sure all pieces are coated—flour helps thicken the juices while it bakes.
- Roll the Dough:
- Split your dough in two. Sprinkle flour on your board then roll one half into a big circle to line your pie plate, easing it into corners but don’t stretch it out.
- Mix Up the Dough:
- Combine flour, salt, and sugar in a bowl. Drop in cubes of refrigerated butter and mash with your hands or a pastry tool until it’s crumbly with some larger bits. Add cold water bit by bit, just until it barely holds when you squish it together.
Pin
Mixing different apples is my favorite trick—it’s what my grandma did when I was little. She’d use whatever was lying around from the orchard and it always came out smelling like her warm kitchen, full of cinnamon and hugs.
Keeping It Fresh
Wrap up extra slices in foil or plastic and pop them in the fridge for a few days. Want it warm again? Stick it back in the oven on low and the crust gets crispy. If you freeze it, slice first and seal tight for the easiest reheating.
Swaps That Work
No worries if you’re short on apples—toss in a few pears and you’ll get a mellow, sweet flavor. Try a gluten-free flour blend if you need, works great in place of the regular stuff. Dairy allergy? Good non-dairy baking margarine does the job instead of butter.
Serving Up Ideas
Scoop up warm slices with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream, for classic vibes. Drizzle caramel sauce if you’re feeling fancy. It’s awesome next to hot coffee or a mug of spiced tea, too.
Pin
Backstory
Brought over from English and Dutch bakers, apple pie became a true American icon in the 1800s. Folks have made it a symbol of homey comfort, and nearly every family adds their special twist to it now.
Recipe FAQs
- → How do you keep the crust flaky?
Work with cold butter and don’t fuss too much with the dough so the fat doesn’t melt. Chilling before rolling makes things extra tender and flaky.
- → Which apples work best for pies?
Go for firmer apples like Honeycrisp, Braeburn, or Granny Smith—they keep their shape and add the right touch of tartness.
- → Why add lemon juice to apples?
Lemon juice brightens up the flavor and also helps stop your apples from turning brown while you’re prepping everything.
- → How can I avoid a soggy bottom crust?
Stick your pie on a lower oven rack and try a metal pan so the bottom crisps up nicely. Avoid too much extra liquid in the filling.
- → Can the pie be served warm?
For sure! Let it cool for tidier slices, but eating it a little warm is awesome—especially with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.