Pin
Cheesy Cajun Chicken Shells mix cozy comfort with a zesty kick. Think tender pasta, loads of melty cheese, and spice that wakes up your taste buds. The roasted peppers add a sweet little pop, and when the pan comes out of the oven bubbling, everyone at my place crowds around for a bite.
I threw these together after a muddy soccer practice, and even my youngest picky eater went back for more. It quickly became our favorite at-home dinner on movie nights or when we're feeding friends who need a little extra comfort.
Tasty Ingredients
- Parsley: Totally optional, but chopped fresh parsley brings pretty green color to your finished dish Go for flat leaf if you've got it
- Garlic powder: Gives the creamy sauce a powerful boost, especially if your fresh garlic isn't hitting hard enough
- Heavy cream: Makes the sauce extra rich Skip the half-and-half, it just won't be the same
- Milk: This is the main base of the sauce—use whole milk if you can for the thickest result
- All-purpose flour: Gets whisked in to help your sauce set up nice and thick Look for unbleached if possible
- Butter: You'll start the sauce with this, making a simple roux Use unsalted so you can salt to taste later
- Parmesan cheese: Grated for bringing salty sharpness to your filling Real Parmigiano or a quality local one is best
- Mozzarella cheese: Grab a block and shred it yourself This way it melts evenly and gets super stretchy
- Ricotta cheese: Smooths out the filling Go with full-fat and try to avoid watery tubs
- Salt and black pepper: You’ll need both to make sure everything tastes just right Sprinkle, taste, repeat
- Paprika: Adds deep smokiness—try a Spanish or Hungarian type for extra flavor
- Cajun seasoning: This blend brings the real zing Choose your favorite or make your own if you love more heat
- Garlic: Fresh minced adds brightness Skip jarred stuff for the best punch
- Red bell pepper: Adds a splash of color and sweetness Pick a heavy, crisp one
- Onion: Chop it up fine White or yellow types work and make sure they're nice and firm
- Olive oil: You’ll use this to sauté veggies and to layer on flavor A mild olive oil works super well
- Cooked chicken: Shred up leftovers or buy rotisserie—white or dark, doesn’t matter
- Jumbo pasta shells: These big guys hold heaps of filling Make sure you get ones without cracks—they'll stuff way easier
Mouthwatering Instructions
- Garnish and Serve:
- Toss on some fresh parsley right before you dig in Dish out three or four shells while they're piping hot
- Bake until Bubbly:
- Pop a tight layer of foil over your baking dish and bake for twenty minutes Yank the foil, then give it another ten minutes so you get those golden cheese spots and bubbling around the edges Let it cool a few so the sauce can set a bit
- Add More Sauce and Cheese:
- Drizzle the rest of your creamy sauce all over the stuffed shells so none are left dry Sprinkle a bunch more mozzarella over the top and get excited for that melt
- Fill and Arrange the Shells:
- Pour half the sauce into the bottom of a big baking dish Scoop filling into each cooled shell—one or two heaping spoonfuls works for each Place them open-side-up nice and snug in the pan
- Make the Creamy Sauce:
- Toss your butter in a saucepan on medium, let it melt Whisk in the flour for about a minute until it's smooth and thick Slowly stream in milk then cream, whisking the whole time so you don’t get lumps Add a little Cajun seasoning and garlic powder, plus salt and pepper Simmer for about five to seven minutes, stirring steady, until it really coats the spoon
- Mix the Filling:
- Move your chicken-veggie mixture to a bowl Stir in the mozzarella, ricotta, and Parmesan Keep mixing until everything is gooey and blended Set it aside for now
- Prepare the Chicken Mixture:
- Drop your shredded chicken into the skillet Sprinkle paprika, Cajun spices, salt, and pepper over the top Mix everything up until the chicken's coated in those spices Slide the pan off the heat and let it rest for five minutes
- Sauté the Vegetables:
- Pour olive oil in a big pan and set it to medium Warm it up, then dump in your chopped onions and peppers Let them soften for about five minutes, stirring now and then Toss in minced garlic and stir for a minute so it doesn't scorch
- Preheat the oven and Cook the Shells:
- Get your oven ready and start boiling a well-salted pot of water Drop in the shells and cook until they’re just barely tender—usually eight or ten minutes Drain, then lay them out so they don’t stick together or fall apart
Pin
The best bit is that crispy golden cheese that bubbles up around the edge after baking uncovered. At our table, those pieces are snatched up first. Always reminds me of watching my grandma grate way too much cheese when I was a kid.
Keeping It Fresh
Leftovers? Store them in a tight container in the fridge for up to three days. To heat back up, cover with foil and bake at three twenty-five until everything's hot—usually around twenty minutes. That keeps the cheese gooey and the shells from drying out.
Swaps and Substitutes
No chicken? Cooked turkey or plant-based chicken works great. Want a cheese with a little more attitude? Switch mozzarella for Monterey Jack. No ricotta? Just blend cottage cheese until creamy and use that.
Ways to Serve
Fresh green salad or even roasted broccoli makes a nice crunchy match with the creamy pasta. Grab some crusty garlic bread if you want to go all in. These shells also shine on a party tray for potlucks or holidays.
History & Inspiration
Stuffed jumbo shells probably started somewhere between Italy and America, but the Cajun edge slides it straight to the South. The spicy Cajun blend comes from Louisiana roots—paprika, cayenne, loads of garlic, and tasty herbs. Mix that with buckets of cheese and pasta and you get a meal that hits every comfort spot.
Pin
Recipe FAQs
- → How do I keep pasta shells from sticking together?
After you cook the shells, spread them out on a baking sheet. Keeping them separate like this means they won’t end up glued together.
- → Can I use rotisserie chicken?
Definitely! Grab a rotisserie chicken, shred it, and toss it into your filling. It’s fast and saves you another cooking step.
- → What type of cheese melts best in this dish?
Go for mozzarella if you want melted, stretchy cheese on top. Ricotta brings a dreamy texture, and Parmesan adds a cheesy kick inside.
- → How do I prevent the sauce from becoming watery?
Simmer the sauce until it’s thick enough to cling to your spoon before using. This keeps your shells from swimming in liquid later.
- → How can I adjust the spice level?
Dial the Cajun seasoning up or down however you like. Toss in a little cayenne if you want extra heat, or use less for a milder bite.
- → Does this dish reheat well?
Yep! Just wrap with foil and warm it up in a low oven until it’s hot and melty all the way through. Tastes just as good the next day.