Pin
This dreamy Italian sausage rigatoni is all about comfort. Think cozy pasta shells smothered in a rich, silky tomato-cream sauce, punched up with herby sausage and bright fresh herbs. It's one of my favorite kitchen wins when I want something warm that brings everyone running to the table.
Honestly, the first time I made this rigatoni, a rainy day turned into cheesy, saucy magic fast. Now it's our go-to on chilly Saturday nights when only the coziest bowl will do.
Winning Ingredients
- Rigatoni pasta: those chunky little tubes are the best for catching chunky sauce grab a brand that stays firm after boiling
- Parmesan cheese: salty, nutty goodness that melts right into the sauce—grate it fresh for best results
- Heavy cream: the trick for ultimate creaminess pick full fat for that dreamy mouthfeel
- Salt and black pepper: makes everything taste bigger use flaky salt and smash your pepper fresh
- Red chili flakes: fires up the whole pot with a hint of background heat
- Fresh oregano or dried: for that earthy zip, go for bright leaves or the best dried you can sniff
- Fresh basil or dried: layer in that sweet, herby top note choose shiny green leaves or fragrant dried
- Whole or crushed tomatoes: brings that punchy tomato flavor if San Marzano is around, you’ll taste the difference
- Garlic cloves: classic bite and aroma pick the fattest, firmest cloves you can
- Large onion: a little sweet and savory richness pick one that feels heavy for its size
- Extra-virgin olive oil: brings depth and helps everything cook its best cold-pressed with a fresh smell is the way to go
- Italian sausage: all the flavor magic right here choose spicy or mild and try your butcher for the best blend
Simple Step Guide
- Finish with Parmesan and Herbs:
- Spoon into bowls, shower with any leftover grated Parmesan and scatter extra fresh basil if you want. Dive in while it’s still steamy for that full creamy effect.
- Mix in Pasta:
- Toss your cooked rigatoni gently into the sauce and let every noodle get a good coating. Need a thicker sauce? Let everything simmer together for a few more minutes until it's clingy perfection.
- Pour in Cream and Cheese:
- While things bubble, add heavy cream, then toss in a cup of Parmesan. Let it all melt together until silky, stirring as you go. Check for seasoning, toss in a little extra salt or pepper if you crave more punch.
- Stir in Tomatoes and Spices:
- Add your tomatoes (blend ‘em smooth if you want) right into the sausage-onion mix. Sprinkle in oregano, basil, red chili flakes, salt, and black pepper. Crank the heat to a boil, then drop to a low bubble for about seven minutes so the flavors all get friendly.
- Boil the Pasta:
- While the sauce simmers, fill up a big pot with salted water and bring it to a hard boil. Cook your rigatoni following the box—usually about ten minutes. Drain and have it waiting.
- Sizzle the Sausage:
- Keep the heat at medium-high and crumble the sausage right onto the onions and garlic. Brown it well, breaking it up as you stir for about eight minutes until you see color and sniff that deep sausage smell.
- Sweat Your Onions and Garlic:
- Start with olive oil and onions in a pan on medium, softening for around eight minutes. Once translucent and smelling nice, stir in the garlic for about a minute until just fragrant.
Pin
Honestly, the part that wins me over every time? All that Parmesan melting right in and making everything so creamy. First forkfuls always turn into grins at our table. A dish that puts everyone in a good mood just can't be beat.
Best Ways to Store
Let it cool off, then scoop into a tight-lid container for the fridge—good up to four days. Warm it up slow on the stove and add a dash of milk or cream if the sauce tightens up. You want to stash some away longer? Freeze in meal-sized packs and thaw overnight in your fridge before reheating.
Swap Options
No sausage? Ground turkey or veggie sausage fit right in. If your pasta shelf is thin, ziti or penne loads up the sauce just as well. Need greens? Stir in some spinach at the end. No Parmesan? Sub in Pecorino or Grana Padano for that sharp, rich touch.
How to Serve
I love to dish it out with green salad and garlic bread—total classic. Grab a bold red wine and really make it feel special. Pile the bowls high and let everyone pile on extra cheese to their own taste.
Pin
Traditional Twist
This dish nods to the home-cooked Sunday pastas all over Italy, but with an Italian-American twist. Bright, fresh tomato and herbs make it lively, while the sausage and cream take it over the top for an extra-rich, crowd-pleasing vibe.
Recipe FAQs
- → What if my sauce gets too thick?
Just pour in a bit of that pasta cooking water slowly and stir it in until you like how it looks.
- → Should I grab fresh herbs or just use dried ones?
Go for fresh basil or oregano if you want brighter flavors, but dried does fine—cut back a little since dried packs more punch.
- → Which Italian sausage should I pick?
Pick whatever you like—spicy or mild Italian sausage are both awesome. Grab a quality one so your sauce turns out super rich and tasty.
- → Can I make this ahead?
Sauce keeps fine if you cook it sooner, but toss the pasta in right before serving. That way your noodles don't soak up too much sauce and go mushy.
- → What's the best way to store leftovers?
Once it's cooled off, stash it in a lidded container in your fridge—good for three days. Reheat slow on the stove or quick in the microwave.
- → Are there good swaps for rigatoni?
You bet! Penne, ziti, or any strong tube-like pasta handles that thick sauce like a pro.