Pin
This rich, soothing New Mexico green chile chicken bake mixes gooey cheese and that can't-miss flavor of the Southwest. I whip it up whenever I want cozy vibes and company, especially when the weather hints at fall. The smoky chiles, juicy chicken, and soft tortillas always draw praise.
After a long New Mexico car trip, this dish was born when I just wanted something that tasted like those tucked-away local diners. Sharing it always gets people talking about their best road trips.
Delicious Ingredients
- Fresh cilantro: Finishes the dish with a pop of freshness Chop it up just before tossing on top for max flavor
- Sour cream: Totally optional Adds extra creaminess Go for full fat if you can
- Hatch green chile sauce or green enchilada sauce: Key for depth and kick Fire-roasted or Hatch brand boosts that New Mexico vibe
- Ground cumin: Gives the filling classic earthy warmth Try freshly ground for more punch
- Garlic: Hits the filling with extra aroma Crushing fresh cloves works best
- Cooked chicken: Shred it up Use rotisserie or roasted—thighs stay juiciest
- Monterey Jack cheese: Grate a block for smooth, stretchy melt Mild and creamy every time
- Corn tortillas: These make the ideal base Briefly heat or steam so they don't crack
- Onion: Diced up, sweated for sweetness Yellow or white both work well
- Cheddar cheese: Shred yourself for full cheese power and best melt Supplies “zing” to the layers
- Salt: Brings everything together Choose kosher or sea for a flavor boost
- Black pepper: Delivers just enough heat and a bit of savory support Crack fresh for the best flavor
Easy Step-by-Step
- Finish and Serve:
- Once it's out of the oven, scatter chopped cilantro over the top Let folks add a big spoonful of sour cream if they like a cool, creamy bite Those extras tie everything together
- Bake Until Golden:
- Slide the casserole in uncovered Bake twenty-five to thirty minutes till the cheese is melted, bubbly, and golden in spots The smell will have everyone in the kitchen
- Sauce and Cheese:
- Pour a bit of chile sauce in the bottom first to stop sticking Tuck rolled tortillas in nice and snug Next, pour the rest of your chile sauce on and scatter leftover cheese for that melty golden finish
- Fill Tortillas and Roll:
- Grab a warm tortilla Add some chicken mixture, then a mix of cheddar and Monterey Jack Roll it up tight Stick the seam side down in your dish Do this till they're all tucked in
- Heat Tortillas:
- Warm tortillas a few at a time—either dry skillet or microwaved in a damp towel just until soft You want them bendy, not stiff
- Fix the Filling:
- Sauté diced onion and garlic in a pan till soft and fragrant Add chicken, cumin, salt, and pepper Stir it together until everything’s heated and flavors start blending
- Ready the Pan:
- Turn your oven to 190°C Smear a bit of oil or butter in your baking pan so nothing sticks
Pin
The Hatch green chile sauce is my go-to here Every time I taste it, I’m back at a cozy Santa Fe cafe Passing the casserole around with family is now a chilly weather must There’s nothing like telling stories over steaming plates of green chile chicken
Leftover Storing Made Simple
Pop leftovers in the fridge, tightly covered, and they’ll keep about three days. All the tastes mingle together and get even better. If you freeze extras, wrap small portions so you can grab one for a quick meal. Let them thaw in your fridge then heat up in the oven or microwave.
Swap Ingredients If You Want
If you only have flour tortillas, they'll work, just expect a softer bite. Grab rotisserie chicken if time's tight—it’s perfect here. No Hatch chiles at your market? Any good green enchilada sauce will get you close, but when possible pick up fire-roasted or canned green chiles for a classic touch.
Serving Ideas
This green chile chicken is filling on its own but goes great with a bright salad—try citrus and avocado—or even a pile of slaw. Some folks serve it as enchilada bake, cutting neat squares for the party table. Want it super Southwest? Add pinto beans or a scoop of guacamole for the win.
Pin
Southwest New Mexico Vibes
This comfort food comes from New Mexico’s unique food culture, where Hatch chiles go in almost everything. Generations have made humble ingredients awesome. You taste history and New Mexico’s sunny desert in every bite, wherever you are.
Recipe FAQs
- → Which green chile sauce tastes the best here?
Go for Hatch green chile sauce if you want that real-deal taste, but quality canned green enchilada sauce totally works if you can’t find Hatch.
- → What if I don’t have corn tortillas—can flour work?
Flour tortillas make things extra soft and mild, but corn tortillas give you that classic flavor and feel.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
Sure thing. Put everything together, cover it, and chill in the fridge for a day. Pop it in the oven when you’re ready to eat.
- → How spicy does this turn out?
The kick really depends on what chile sauce you use. Pick mild or medium if you want to keep the heat down, or add more chiles for a spicy punch.
- → What can I serve on the side?
Try this with refried beans, Spanish rice, or a crunchy green salad. Sour cream and cilantro are always nice extras on top.
- → Is it okay to freeze leftovers?
Absolutely. Let it cool, slice it up, wrap tightly, and freeze. Warming it in the oven keeps the texture just right.