Pin
You’re looking at a delightfully messy version of everyone’s favorite Italian-American comfort food. Juicy ground chicken, marinara, and not just one but two cheeses come together in a piled-high sandwich you’ll want again and again. I grew up loving the old-school sloppy joe, and now this upgraded twist is my first pick whenever I want cozy food that’s a little fancy but still low-key for guests.
These Chicken Parmesan Sloppy Joes landed on my menu the night friends dropped by for a last-minute football watch. Everybody went nuts for them, and now they’re the food my crew always asks for at laid-back hangouts.
Ingredients
- Garlic butter: Spreads onto the buns for a flavorful shield that keeps them crisp and tasty. Whip some up fast with softened butter, minced garlic, and some herbs.
- Parmesan cheese: Packs a salty, nutty punch that ties the whole thing together. Grab a hunk and grate it fresh for the best gooey result.
- Basil pesto: This little number sneaks in big flavor with fresh, herbal notes. Chilled pesto works better than shelf-stable—trust me.
- Marinara sauce: Kicks in all that classic Italian goodness. A good jar is fine, but homemade is always a winner if you’ve got time.
- Brioche buns: Sweet and rich, these buns soak up the filling but don’t get too soggy. Bakery fresh is ideal if you can swing it.
- Mozzarella cheese: Offers that epic cheesy stretch everyone loves about chicken parm. Stick with low moisture mozzarella for best melt.
- Yellow onion: The tastiest base for your filling. Grab onions that feel firm and skip any soft ones.
- Ground chicken: Soaks up all the sauce and keeps things lighter than using beef. Lean is great, but don’t go super lean or the flavor will suffer.
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Finish and Serve:
- Set the top buns over your sandwiches and, if you like, toss on some torn basil. Dig in and eat while everything’s still warm, the cheese is gooey, and the bread’s a little crisp. Every bite should give you all those classic flavors and textures folks crave from this mashup.
- Add the Mozzarella:
- Toss mozzarella over the steaming chicken mixture. If you’re after maximum melt, pop the sandwiches (bottoms only) back in the oven for another minute or two. You want the cheese stretchy but not lost in the sauce.
- Load Up Your Buns:
- Grab those toasted bun bottoms, place them on plates, and generously heap on the hot chicken. Go for a nice mound but don’t overdo it—you still want to pick these up!
- Toast Your Brioche:
- Slide your bun halves (cut sides up) onto a baking sheet. Spread with garlicky butter so they come out flavorful and toasty, not soggy. Bake in a 400°F oven for 5-ish minutes until golden around the edges, but watch close—brioche can brown in a flash.
- Melt in the Parmesan:
- Turn the stove down low, shower the chicken mixture with parmesan, and mix it in. This makes your filling creamy and gives it that signature chicken parm zing. Let it all bubble gently together while you work on the buns.
- Build the Sauce:
- Tip in your marinara, scoop in the pesto, plus salt and pepper. Stir everything together until the chicken’s totally coated. Let it bubble softly—should be thick enough for a bun, yet still juicy.
- Sauté Those Onions:
- Diced onion goes straight into the pan with your cooking chicken. Keep things moving so the onion softens and goes see-through, scraping up any flavorful brown bits. You’re looking at just a few more minutes here.
- Brown Your Chicken:
- Start by firing up a skillet over medium-high. Crumble the ground chicken into the pan and keep it breaking apart as it cooks. No need to drain like beef, since chicken doesn’t have much fat. Cook till it’s lost its pink color and the edges get a little golden—about 5 to 7 minutes. Don’t skimp on the browning; it really boosts flavor.
Pin
The real game changer here is the basil pesto. I only tossed it in because I ran out of my regular Italian blend one night—turns out, it totally kicked up the flavor. Even my nephew, who normally won’t touch “green stuff,” begs for seconds every single time I make these.
Pin
Make Ahead Magic
Great news—this chicken mix only gets better after a night in the fridge, so you can make it in advance. When it’s time to eat, just warm it up in a skillet with a splash of water or broth if it’s gotten too thick. Toast fresh bread right before serving so you get that perfect crispy-soft combo. The chicken mix will keep well for up to three days in a sealed container in the fridge.
Switch It Up Your Way
This meal is super flexible based on what you like or need. Want to go easy on the carbs? Skip the bun and serve everything over spaghetti squash or zucchini ribbons. More veggies in your life? Throw in diced bell pepper or shredded zucchini with the chicken. If you love spicy, shake in red pepper flakes or add some hot giardiniera on top. To make it even heartier, sauté some mushrooms and mix ‘em in for earthy depth.
Ways to Serve
These sandwiches pair up well with the right extras. Try a lemony arugula salad for a fresh bite that cuts the richness. Want something cozier? Garlic-parm fries hit the spot. Roasted broccoli topped with a little parmesan is another solid pick if you want to keep it lighter. If you’re feeding a party crowd, make mini versions with soft dinner rolls instead of full buns—they’re perfect for snacking without getting too full.
Behind the Mashup
This dish smashes together two comfort food all-stars: American sloppy joes and Italian chicken parmesan. Chicken parmesan itself came from Italian Americans swapping in chicken for eggplant, but turning it into a saucy sandwich takes things even further. You get all the essentials—cheesy, saucy, garlicky goodness—in a casual, pick-it-up-and-eat format that’s perfect for quick dinners and cozy nights in.
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I switch ground chicken with ground turkey?
Definitely! Use ground turkey instead and you'll barely notice. The taste comes out close and it's still lean, just a tiny bit different texture. All that marinara and cheese make it awesome either way.
- → What’s the trick to keeping my buns from ending up soggy?
You want to first toast the buns in garlic butter so they're sturdy and tasty. Then, wait to load up your sandwiches until everyone's ready to eat, or keep your chicken mix and buns in separate bowls until serving.
- → Got a good side dish to go with these Chicken Parm Sloppy Joes?
For sides, a crisp Caesar or simple green salad is perfect. You could also go for roasted veggies like peppers or zucchini, or whip up some Parmesan fries. If you're really hungry, try some pasta salad or crunchy potatoes on the side.
- → Can I make the chicken filling before I need it?
Yep, you can totally prep the meat part early. It actually tastes better the next day once the herbs and sauce settle in more. Just stash it in a sealed dish in the fridge (up to three days), then warm it up on the stove or microwave when you're ready. Toast fresh buns and dig in.
- → Is this dish spicy? Can I up the heat?
This one's pretty mellow as made, but you can add more kick easy. Throw in crushed red pepper, choose a spicy marinara, or shake in some cayenne when cooking. Or simply keep hot sauce handy for folks who want to turn up the fire.
- → What if I need to make this gluten-free?
No problem. Just grab your fave gluten-free burger buns. Everything else—chicken, cheese, sauce—is usually gluten-free already. It's smart to double-check bottles of pesto or marinara, just in case they sneak gluten in there.