Save
Velvety and super easy with only five basics this Alfredo is what I whip up when I want comfort fast I love how something so simple can turn a no-frills meal into something that feels fancy right at home
The first time I tried this was for friends and they kept asking if it was takeout Totally changed my mind about Alfredo from scratch being tough It’s actually a breeze
Luscious Ingredients
- Salt and black pepper: lift the other flavors and let you make it just right for you Freshly ground pepper’s the way to go
- Garlic: gives a mellow kick that cuts through all the richness Go for firm cloves for that top aroma
- Parmesan cheese: brings nutty, salty magic Always grate it yourself right before for the dreamiest melt Skip the bag stuff if you can
- Heavy cream: makes it all lush and silken Grab cream with zero additives if possible
- Unsalted butter: makes things smooth and rich Pick one with good yellow color for best taste
Step-by-Step Guide
- Season and Finish
- Check your sauce’s taste and add pepper and salt as you like Kill the heat when it’s thick and glossy and covers a spoon nicely Pour it onto your noodles and dig in right away
- Add Parmesan Cheese
- Toss in the parmesan a bit at a time while stirring Let it melt down and the sauce get thick and smooth This bit really makes it creamy
- Simmer the Cream
- Now pour in your cream and heat gently so bubbles just start around the edge Give it a couple of minutes and stir now and then so it comes together and gets just a bit thicker
- Sauté the Garlic
- Drop your chopped garlic into the melted butter and cook for a minute or two Keep stirring so it doesn’t get brown Stop as soon as it smells bright—this does the trick without bitterness
- Melt Butter
- Get your pan on medium and add butter Let it fully melt and get a little foamy That’s the starting point and helps the sauce come together later
At our house, Parmesan’s the big deal I buy a slab of Parmigiano Reggiano and grate it fresh My kids say the cheese melting into the sauce is their favorite Once, I tossed in some Gouda for fun and now they beg for it
How to Store
Spoon leftovers into a tight container and stick in the fridge up to three days It’ll get thicker as it sits Warm it up slow and low while stirring and add a splash of milk or cream as needed to get it creamy Don’t crank up the heat high or the sauce can separate
Swap-Outs
Ran out of heavy cream? Use half and half for a less rich version but cook a little longer to get it thicker Want it even richer? Add a dollop of mascarpone or a chunk of cream cheese Amp up the flavor with some pecorino romano swapped in for the Parmesan
Ways to Serve
Fettuccine is classic, for sure, but honestly this sauce works on almost anything Mix it with broccoli, pour over crispy chicken, or spoon on a hot baked potato One time I served it as a dip with warm breadsticks for a birthday and it disappeared in minutes
History and Background
This sauce started in Rome but what you find in America is way richer Alfredo di Lelio made it famous by serving it to Hollywood stars back in the 1920s Now it’s a comfort staple here because it’s super creamy and always a crowd-pleaser
Frequently Asked Cooking Questions
- → Which Parmesan gives the best melt?
Go for freshly grated Parmesan because it melts so much better and tastes stronger. The pre-shredded stuff just doesn’t work as well.
- → Could I swap the heavy cream for milk or half and half?
If you want a lighter feel, use half and half. Heavy cream makes it thick and rich. Milk’s okay, but your sauce will be runnier.
- → What keeps this sauce from getting lumpy?
Sprinkle in the Parmesan bit by bit over low heat and keep stirring. If you use pre-shredded cheese, it’ll want to clump more.
- → How do I save leftovers?
Let it cool, pop it in an airtight container, and stash it in the fridge for up to three days. When you want more, warm it up low and slow, stirring to get that smooth feel back.
- → Got a pasta that works best here?
Big noodles are your friend! Fettuccine or linguine scoop up the sauce perfectly.