Pin
Picture a mug of hot chocolate so smooth and cozy it chases away the cold nights. With chocolatey goodness and rich peanut butter, this drink feels like a nostalgic, sweet hug you’ll want again and again.
The first time I tried peanut butter swirled with chocolate, I was a kid. Never thought I'd be making this drink for movie night and getting constant requests for refills from the family.
Creamy Ingredient Lineup
- Granulated sugar: Makes it sweet and smooth. White sugar melts best.
- Milk: This is the base for your drink. Whole milk is best for thickness, but others work too.
- Unsweetened cocoa powder: Gives an intense chocolate kick. Dutch process brings a softer taste.
- Water: Blends your cocoa and sugar together lump-free. Cool, filtered water is perfect.
- Creamy peanut butter: Brings in nutty creaminess. Skip the runny natural stuff.
- Peanut butter sauce: Optional, for more peanut punch. Make it quick or grab store-bought.
- Whipped cream: Optional, tops things off light and fluffy. Fresh or canned both work.
Simple Steps to Sip
- Serve and Top:
- Pour that steamy chocolate into your go-to mug. Pick your fanciest, or just your favorite to hold. Pile on whipped cream and zigzag peanut butter sauce to look like a pro barista.
- Blend in Milk and Peanut Butter:
- Pour in your milk, add that scoop of creamy peanut butter, and really stir it. Warm it slow until steamy and everything’s silky and melted before turning off the heat.
- Combine Dry Ingredients and Water:
- In a little saucepan, mix up your cocoa, sugar, and water. Warm it on medium, keep stirring, and wait for it to look glossy with no clumps before the next step.
Pin
My favorite little moment? Watching peanut butter melt into the chocolate. Every sip makes me remember those classic PB and chocolate candies from when I was a kid. When I first topped someone else's mug with extra cream, my niece’s grin was unforgettable—now this is my go-to for family nights.
Storing Leftovers
Stash any extra in the fridge with a cover for up to two days. Warm it gently on the stove while giving it a stir so it stays creamy. Wait to add whipped cream until you’re about to drink it.
Easy Ingredient Swaps
Need it without dairy? Try oat, soy, or almond milk for creamy sips. Use sunflower butter if you can’t do peanuts. Want something bold? Go for dark cocoa and sweeten to your liking.
Fun Ways to Enjoy
Pour it up in your favorite cup. Add more whipped cream, toss on mini chocolate chips, or dust with cinnamon if that’s your vibe. So good with shortbread, popcorn, or even a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top.
Pin
Warm Cultural Touch
For years, folks everywhere have turned to hot chocolate for comfort. Tossing in peanut butter is a modern spin—think classic American candies and childhood peanut treats. Anytime I want a fresh take, I go straight for this mix.
Recipe FAQs
- → Is natural peanut butter okay here?
Stick with regular creamy peanut butter. The natural kind can split and leave the drink kind of gritty.
- → What if I want it dairy-free?
Just swap out the milk with oat, soy, or almond milk—any plant milk will do the trick and still taste awesome.
- → Can I whip this up using the microwave?
Totally, just stir together cocoa, sugar, water, and peanut butter in your mug. Add the milk, then nuke it until it’s super hot.
- → What can I pile on top of my mug?
Whipped cream is a classic, but try swirling on some warm peanut butter, tiny marshmallows, or shave a bit of chocolate on there too.
- → How do I throw together a peanut butter drizzle?
Mix up some peanut butter with corn syrup, warm it in the microwave till it bubbles, then stir until it looks smooth and glossy.